That image above is the latest spammy writer email I’ve received. I figured it would be fun to go fisking through it. Join me, won’t you?
Dear Barry,
Notice how the font for “Barry” is different from the rest of the email. Classic sign of mail merge. You’d think scammers would avail themselves of the absolutely free technology that obviates this tell, but…no.
I hope you’re well.
I don’t believe that for a minute.
My name is Jenny Lin,
No, it’s not.
and I work independently in literary and screen development in Los Angeles.
No, you don’t.
I collaborate with producers and development executives who are actively looking for distinctive material with strong cinematic potential for film, television, and streaming.
Again, no, you don’t.
I came across your work and was intrigued by the possibility of how the story could translate to the screen. At the development stage, I’m particularly interested in projects with a compelling premise, strong character arcs, an identifiable visual world, and a narrative hook that can sustain an audience beyond the page.
Right.
I’d like to take a closer look at the property and get a sense of its adaptation potential. If the material feels like a strong fit, I can then determine whether it makes sense to introduce the project to a producer or development executive within my network.
Have you noticed something here? First of all, in this paragraph and the previous, “Jenny Lin” (let’s face it — there’s no such person) refers to “your work” and “the story” and “the property.” Nothing is named. I’ve published 30 books and a bunch of short stories. Which one are talking about, Jenny??? Which one has “a compelling premise, strong character arcs, an identifiable visual world, and a narrative hook that can sustain an audience beyond the page???” Tell me!!!
Also: Note that she wants to get a closer look. Well, according to the previous paragraph, she’s already come “across [my] work and was intrigued by the possibility of how the story could translate to the screen.” So…if you want a closer look, just look closer, Jenny Lin! You must have “the work” at your disposal since it’s already so intrigues you. Take a look! Take a closer look!
For an initial development review, please send:
• Title and genre
Wait, what??? You are intrigued by my work, but don’t even know the title and genre?!
• Logline or brief synopsis
My work has “a compelling premise, strong character arcs, an identifiable visual world, and a narrative hook that can sustain an audience beyond the page,” but you haven’t even seen so much as a synopsis?
• Link to the book or a representative excerpt
If you’re so captivated by my work, shouldn’t you already have a link to the book?
• Current film/television rights status
• Best contact number and time zone
If you’d rather speak first, you’re welcome to send your preferred number and a convenient time for a brief call.
In the words of Blue Beetle: BWA-HA-HA-HA! There is no way in hell I would give you my phone number!
There is no obligation or fee associated with this initial review. At this stage, the goal is simply to assess the property’s creative and commercial potential and determine whether there is a meaningful path toward further development.
Oh, at this stage, there is no obligation or fee! Got it. But the obligations and fees will come later.
The strongest adaptations begin with a story that already has something cinematic at its core: a distinctive world, characters audiences want to follow, meaningful conflict, and a reason the story belongs on screen.
Why are we back to this?
I’d be interested to see whether your work has that potential.
Best regards,
Jenny Lin
Independent Literary & Screen Development
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email and any materials shared for development consideration are intended solely for the recipient and should be treated as confidential. Please do not reproduce, distribute, or disclose any unpublished material without authorization. If received in error, please notify the sender and delete this message and any attachments.
The confidentiality notice is a nice touch. Designed to make me think this is a Big Deal and Official.
Beyond everything I said above, the weirdest goddamn thing about this spam is that the subject line is “A Stranger in a Strange Land.” With absolutely no reference to this subject line or to Heinlein’s sci-fi classic or to any sort of theme in my work. What the living hell, Jenny Lin?