These are the original comments from the old barrylyga.com. To add a comment, return to the BLog page.
Great Idea’s
By: SRMcEvoy
on Tue June 22, 2010, 12:39:48
Stevenhttp://www.bookreviewsandmore.ca
Re: What’s Wrong with Publishing? #5: Digital Dreams
By: Eugene
on Tue June 22, 2010, 13:40:02
If publishers offered a free or discounted e-book download with the purchase of the tree version, it wouldn’t cost them any extra and it would prevent readers from having to make the choice. Sometimes I want the convenience of an e-book, but prefer to own a hardcopy for my collection. (This is why I have mass market editions of some books like Lord of the Rings and His Dark Materials, but beautiful hardcovers editions to keep.)
Re: What’s Wrong with Publishing? #5: Digital Dreams
By: Dee Beutel
on Tue June 22, 2010, 14:41:32
Taking this one step further, there could also be a “Did you like Super Sexy Superman by Hottie McHotpants? Check out these similar titles…” If the links are there, and it is easy to click through and download, I think it would be an easy way to generate more sales.
short fiction
By: Jon Skovron
on Tue June 22, 2010, 15:51:30
Also I think e-books could make the shorter forms into a more viable market. Short stories and novellas have always had distribution problems. It’s too much work for too little. It wouldn’t be worthwhile to produce a paper novella for $5 perhaps, but a digital one? Maybe so? Using iBook on my iPad, I could see myself gleefully bleeding small amounts of money on $3 short here, an $5 novella there, authors making money in a model very similar to the way iPhone App developers do. Because, “Hey, it’s just a couple bucks” adds up. Would that alone pay the rent? Probably not. But it would be a nice suppliment.
Re: What’s Wrong with Publishing? #5: Digital Dreams
By: fivecats
on Tue July 06, 2010, 08:57:19
he gave us a spreadsheet with all of the numbers and it was amazing. this was one of our best selling titles and it still hadn’t made back the initial cost of publication.
without going into detail, the in-house costs associated with acquiring, proofing, typesetting and proofing again, are very high. add in the cost of printing, shipping and warehousing and it gets even higher.
as an IT guy, i came in pushing for a paradigm shift in the way the press approached their goal. they had been thinking the goal was a printed, bound collection of folio pages (a “book”). i wanted them to refocus their goal to Content — flexible content.
that shift is taking place here (finally). the think is, however, from the publisher’s side of things, the costs associated with producing an ebook are still being worked out. you can’t just take a Word document and do a Save As… Kindle. there’s an entire process of coverting the text (and, in our case, all of the illustrations, tables, charts, maps, etc) into XHTML that can then be converted into .MOBI for the Kindle. (other e-readers use different formats, of course)
then there’s the need to proof that converted file. (another well-known university publishing house discovered this the hard way when someone purchased an e-book from them and then complained loudly because the file was missing everything after Chapter Three) actually, make that “proof each separate converted file.”
one of the things the DVD industry has learned that the recorded music industry has never gotten is the need to give consumers “something extra.” i’m one of those people who love the DVD extras. if i buy a DVD (or even rent one) that doesn’t come with extras, i feel cheated.
a while back, in my personal blog, i wrote about being disappointed that i had to cut a scene from my WIP. it was a funny scene, but one that no longer fit in the book after i restructured the first four chapters. i thought about posting it to my web site in a “deleted scenes” section. several people commented that they thought this was a great idea. doing the same thing with an e-book strikes me as a great way of combining the DVD extras with the e-book format.
and once a title has been parsed (and proofed) into e-book format it makes perfect sense to give teasers for your other titles. that is a fantastic idea.
…
Re: What’s Wrong with Publishing? #5: Digital Dreams
By: Barry
on Tue July 06, 2010, 10:05:36
The Astonishing Adventures of Fanboy and Goth Girl
By: Caitlin
on Sun July 11, 2010, 21:05:27
Re: What’s Wrong with Publishing? #5: Digital Dreams
By: Barry
on Tue July 13, 2010, 17:35:41
Right now, there are no plans for a third book about Fanboy and Goth Girl, but you know what? I never planned to write the second book, either! So there’s no way to know — it may happen. And those two characters may show up in the background of some other books, too.
Interesting take, I must say
By: Hanna
on Fri July 16, 2010, 00:14:04
But, I also understand financial issues with the shipping, binding, page folding, etcetera about physical books.
Although I must argue that staring at a screen and reading just does not appeal to me. There’s a whole feeling (for me anyway) that just overtakes me whenever I open up a book and just smell the bound pages. Same goes for walking into a library or a bookstore– the smell just hits, and I just have to delve into it. The same can’t go for digital books. You just can’t FEEL the book in your palm, with its paper-cover. I probably sound like an old crank here, but hey, whatever.
And there’s that feeling of having a big bookshelf full of books at home, you know? I come home, go into my room and see my bookshelves nearly overflowing with the books I’ve bought (mostly YA fiction, but I’ve got reference books and such), and I’m like, “Huh. This defines me.”
I’m hoping to add both “The Astonishing Adventures of Fanboy and Goth Girl” and “Goth Girl Rising” to the collection once I get the money (financial, right?), because it turns out that the stories remind me of my own life.
I first read “FB&GG” (is the acronym irritating?) a few years back after I saw it at Border’s, then I got it at the library and thought it was kinda weird. I reread it again yesterday, and then read “Goth Girl Rising” today, and my reaction had changed.
First of all, I understood more of the graphic novel references, because since I’d last read “FB&GG” I’d gone through Neil Gaiman novels and some deathly-looking graphic novels, but there was also the aspect of Kyra and Fanboy’s relationship being similar to me and my friends.
I mean, there are SOME similarities, but most of what happens in the book have not happened to me (flashing, stealing cars, kicking him in the gonads…). When I finished reading “Goth Girl Rising” (which admittedly was about twenty minutes ago), I thought back and realized how well you portrayed Kyra. The female part of her, it was just so amazing, coming from a dude. Especially because a lot of what Kyra said, I’d thought to myself before, or believed in. I thought of basically everything she said in the book, other than a) mother dying (since mine is alive), b) destroying Fanboy (just too cruel. Thought of my own friend and cringed from thinking about doing that to him), and c) calling my father by his first name.
What she said about her own body, what she thought about people, how she struggled through her release from the hospital– it felt so real and amazing to think “Oh hey, I did this…”
It truly was an amazing read. I was awed, and I’m pretty much dying to know what happens next. And believe me, I’m telling that friend (the one that’s slightly a version of Fanboy) about this book. I’m not sure what he’ll think, but I don’t think I really have anything to lose.
…This turned from an opposing argument to a fan-letter. Wow. I shall now go do something productive.
All in all, the argument about the e-book was good. Great points. I’ll keep them in mind.