Kirkus and Booklist have weighed in on Boy Toy, each in their September 1, 2007 editions, with Kirkus giving the book a starred review.

You can check them out on the Boy Toy review page. Here are a couple of excerpts:

  • Kirkus: “…a tightly paced narrative that explores psychological turmoil without resorting to either clinical terminology or oversimplification. Authentic and fresh….”
  • Booklist: “Teens, who think they know so much about sexuality, may see the subject in a new way here.”